Get the Compensation You Deserve SCHEDULE A FREE CONSULTATION
Insurance agent holding pen medical insurance, the policy
SJP Sifers Jensen Palmer March 30, 2025

Navigating Mass Tort Cases: A Guide for Injured Plaintiffs

Mass tort cases allow multiple plaintiffs to pursue claims against a defendant whose actions caused widespread harm. Unlike class actions, where plaintiffs share a single lawsuit, mass torts involve individual claims combined for efficiency. 

Understanding how mass torts work can help injured plaintiffs protect their rights and pursue appropriate compensation.

At SJP Sifers Jensen Palmer, our experienced attorneys can help you through this process. We have, and continue to, represent clients nationwide recovering hundreds of millions is settlements. Take advantage of our free consultations, and let our experienced attorneys evaluate your case.

An Overview of Mass Tort Cases

Mass tort cases arise when a defective product, hazardous drug, or harmful action affects a large number of people. Each plaintiff files an individual claim, but the cases are consolidated for pretrial proceedings to promote consistency and efficiency. 

Despite being part of a larger group, plaintiffs retain control over their individual cases and outcomes.

Common types of mass tort cases include:

  • Defective medical devices that cause injuries

  • Dangerous prescription drugs with severe side effects

  • Exposure to toxic substances resulting in long-term health problems

  • Product defects that cause physical harm or financial loss

Each case focuses on how the defendant’s actions harmed individual plaintiffs, making mass torts distinct from class actions.

Determining Eligibility for a Mass Tort Case

To determine eligibility for a mass tort case, plaintiffs must establish that they suffered harm caused by the defendant’s product or action. Meeting this threshold typically involves demonstrating:

  • Exposure to the harmful product or substance

  • A direct link between the exposure and the resulting harm

  • Measurable damages, such as medical expenses or lost income

Individuals who meet these criteria may have grounds to participate in a mass tort case. Consulting our attorneys to determine whether your claim aligns with the broader mass tort litigation.

Filing an Individual Claim Within a Mass Tort

Filing an individual claim within a mass tort allows plaintiffs to seek compensation while benefiting from coordinated pretrial proceedings. Each claim remains separate, meaning plaintiffs present their unique circumstances and damages. 

This approach allows for more tailored outcomes than class action lawsuits, where a single settlement applies to all plaintiffs.

The filing process typically involves submitting detailed information about the injury, the product or substance involved, and the damages incurred. This information helps establish the connection between the defendant’s actions and the harm suffered.

Participating in Consolidated Pretrial Proceedings

Mass tort cases often undergo consolidated pretrial proceedings to streamline evidence gathering and promote consistency. These proceedings, known as multidistrict litigation (MDL), allow courts to handle common legal issues efficiently. 

During this phase, attorneys conduct discovery, gather evidence, and address motions that apply to all cases.

Consolidating pretrial proceedings helps avoid duplicative efforts and inconsistent rulings. Once the pretrial phase concludes, individual cases may proceed to trial or settlement discussions.

An Overview of Bellwether Trials

Bellwether trials play an important role in mass tort cases. These trials involve a small number of representative cases selected to proceed to trial first. The outcomes of these cases provide information on how juries may respond to evidence and arguments, influencing settlement discussions for remaining claims.

Although bellwether trial results don’t bind other plaintiffs, they can shape the direction of the litigation and impact negotiations between parties.

Evaluating Potential Compensation

Compensation in mass tort cases varies depending on the individual circumstances of each plaintiff. Factors influencing compensation may include:

  • The severity of the injury and its long-term effects

  • Medical expenses incurred for treatment and rehabilitation

  • Lost income and diminished earning capacity

  • Pain, suffering, and emotional distress caused by the injury

Since mass torts involve individual claims, compensation is tailored to each plaintiff’s losses rather than being divided equally among all participants.

Recognizing the Difference Between Mass Torts and Class Actions

Mass torts and class actions are similar but also differ in important ways. In class actions, plaintiffs with similar claims combine their cases into a single lawsuit, and any settlement or verdict applies equally to all members. 

By contrast, mass torts allow plaintiffs to pursue individual claims while benefiting from coordinated pretrial proceedings. They also provide greater control over individual outcomes, making them more suitable for cases where damages and injuries vary widely among plaintiffs.

Investigating the Defendant’s Liability

Establishing liability in a mass tort case requires demonstrating that the defendant’s actions caused harm to the plaintiffs. This often involves gathering evidence such as:

  • Internal documents revealing knowledge of risks

  • Expert testimony explaining the link between exposure and harm

  • Medical records supporting the extent of the plaintiff’s injuries

Building a strong case involves presenting this evidence effectively to show that the defendant’s negligence or misconduct directly caused the harm.

Statutes of Limitations

Statutes of limitations establish deadlines for filing mass tort claims, and these deadlines vary by state. Having represented clients all over the country, SJP Law Firm is familiar with the statute of limitations in every state.

Failing to file within the applicable deadline can bar plaintiffs from pursuing compensation. Understanding these time limits is essential for protecting legal rights.

Exploring Settlement Options

Settlement negotiations play a significant role in mass tort cases. After bellwether trials or during pretrial proceedings, parties may engage in settlement discussions to resolve remaining claims. Settlements provide plaintiffs with compensation without the uncertainty of a trial.

When evaluating settlement offers, plaintiffs should consider whether the amount adequately covers their medical expenses, lost income, and other damages. Accepting a settlement typically means waiving the right to pursue further legal action, so careful consideration is essential.

Proceeding to Trial When Necessary

If settlement negotiations don’t lead to a satisfactory resolution, individual cases may proceed to trial. At trial, plaintiffs present evidence, call witnesses, and argue their case before a jury. Since each mass tort case is handled individually, the outcome depends on the strength of the evidence and the circumstances of the case.

A successful trial verdict can provide compensation for damages and hold the defendant accountable for its actions.

Addressing Challenges in Mass Tort Cases

Mass tort cases present unique challenges that require careful attention. Plaintiffs must balance the benefits of participating in coordinated litigation with the need to protect their individual interests. 

Staying informed about case developments and maintaining communication with legal counsel can help plaintiffs stay engaged throughout the process.

Addressing challenges early can help plaintiffs avoid misunderstandings and maintain control over their claims.

Managing Medical Records and Documentation

Accurate medical records and documentation play a critical role in supporting mass tort claims. Plaintiffs should maintain comprehensive records, including:

  • Medical reports detailing diagnoses and treatment plans

  • Records of medications prescribed and side effects experienced

  • Documentation of medical expenses and related costs

Organizing this information effectively helps strengthen a claim and demonstrates the extent of the injury.

Evaluating Long-Term Impacts of Injuries

Mass tort plaintiffs often experience long-term effects from their injuries, which can influence compensation and settlement decisions. Evaluating the future impact of an injury involves considering:

  • Ongoing medical treatment and rehabilitation needs

  • Potential loss of earning capacity

  • Emotional and psychological effects caused by the injury

Recognizing these long-term effects helps plaintiffs assess the full value of their claims and pursue appropriate compensation.

An Overview of Multidistrict Litigation (MDL)

Multidistrict litigation (MDL) consolidates similar cases from different jurisdictions to streamline pretrial proceedings. In mass tort cases, MDL reduces duplicative discovery and promotes consistent rulings. After the pretrial phase, individual cases may return to their original courts for trial or settlement discussions.

MDL allows for efficient case management while preserving plaintiffs’ rights to pursue individual claims.

Protecting Pers Rights Throughout the Process

Plaintiffs participating in mass tort cases should take steps to protect their personal injury rights throughout the process. This involves staying informed about case developments, responding to requests for information, and reviewing settlement offers carefully. 

Protecting these rights helps maintain control over the case and increases the likelihood of achieving a fair outcome.

Monitoring Case Developments and Deadlines

Staying informed about case developments and deadlines helps plaintiffs remain engaged in the litigation process. Courts may issue orders that affect procedural timelines, and plaintiffs must comply with these requirements to preserve their claims. 

Monitoring these developments makes sure that plaintiffs stay on track and meet necessary obligations.

Call SJP Sifers Jensen Palmer Today to Get Started

Mass tort cases provide injured plaintiffs with an opportunity to seek compensation while benefiting from coordinated pretrial proceedings. At SJP Sifers Jensen Palmer, our attorneys serve clients nationwide. Call today to get started with our services.


RECENT POSTS

How to Determine Liability in Semi-Truck Accident Cases  -

When you’re involved in a semi-truck accident, determining liability is essential for getting the compensation you deserve. Accidents with large commercial vehicles are significantly different from standard car accidents, and understanding who is at fault can be tricky.

Read More